Elizabeth McCracken responds to the pull of grief. She embraces and succumbs to it with a fresh and frank examination of grief in all its components. And she does it well.
Elizabeth and her husband Edward’s son is born while they are luxuriating in France – a stillborn. They have called him Pudding all through the pregnancy and Elizabeth continues to do so. A year and 5 days later, their second son is born. While Pudding was born in France, her second child is born in Saratoga Springs, New York in 2007. As Elizabeth chronicles her pain and the solid truth of grief, she remembers writing in Bordeaux: “This is the happiest story in the world with the saddest ending.” She puzzles over how happy she was, how joyous she and her husband were, living pregnant in Bordeaux. And then the impossible happened. I immediately thought of the book, “When Bad Things Happen to Good People,” but Elizabeth states the truth about herself. Her sadness and grief are just that – sadness and grief. Her baby is still dead. And as we read through her daily struggles we gain insight into what it’s really like, losing a child, the moment to moment living of it. Like William Styron’s book about his horrible depression, the days slide by, but you are in another country. Alone.
Both Elizabeth and Edward are writers. Through Elizabeth’s eyes, we see her travel through the numbness, the despair, and how she implements humor and “just keep going” to survive. One of her most poignant moments are when people ask her if her second infant is her first child. “How many children do I have?” she asks herself. “How many are there of me?” She speaks of her second pregnancy – of making no plans, of walking on eggshells, of leaving France never to return. As she relates her experiences – the pain of friends saying the wrong things, the pain of friends not saying anything, the loss when she hears of another friend having a healthy baby, Elizabeth leads us into the chaos and uncertainty of loss. But she needs the recognition that there had been a Pudding, her son, and the condolences, she writes, “felt like oxygen.” Her rage, her friend Lib who emailed her daily, the small and large things that kept her sane; this journal like memoir carries everything of Elizabeth’s heart and mind. They do not seek to know the second baby’s gender, it is too hard.
Reading this astounding book of Elizabeth’s life with Edward, with her doctors, with the terror of her second baby hovering in her belly when Pudding was still – would always be – I felt startled with the amazing story of the human capacity to endure. Her self recriminations, guilt, the love of her husband Edward through it all – this is one memoir, though difficult to read, must be read. As Elizabeth holds Pudding in the sling of her heart and balances the thought of another child living inside her, we feel her struggle. And although we can not feel her pain, we can touch it.
Ratings are based on a 5-star scale
Plot: 4.5
Characters: 4.5
Presentation: 4.5
Overall: 4.5
Book Review by Broad “A” – Ava
An Exact Replica of a Figment of My Imagination is available for purchase at Amazon.com
Thank you to the Hachette Book Group for providing this title for our book review as well as this giveaway. We were in no way paid or compensated for our opinions.
Enter Daily
Extra Entries
- Become a fan of The Broads on Facebook <<< NEW!
- Blog about this giveaway on YOUR blog!
- Follow the Review Broads – on the sidebar
- Subscribe to The Review Broads for FREE
- Link to this giveaway on your Facebook page
- Follow Bro’B’s new blog – I Pity the Blog
- Follow Broad “Z” on twitter.
- Grab our badge from the sidebar and add it to your site.
- Twitter this giveaway.
- Be sure to leave a comment letting me know if you’ve done any of these (if you already subscribe or have our badge – please note that in the comments as well).
Please make sure you leave your email address when adding a comment or I will not be able to contact you if you win.
* This giveaway is open to US residents, 18 and over and ends on February 24, 2010 11:59 EST.
* The winner will be randomly chosen and contacted via email.
* The winner has 48 hours to respond to my email or an alternate winner will be chosen.
* Please make sure you check your junk mail folder
* Good Luck
Chip says
I'm a fan on Facebook. Would love this book. I've read it, and the author did such a wonderful job writing about such a sad subject. I wish I had such a way with words.
Jill L
chipdip2010(at)hotmail(dot)com
Chip says
I'm a fan on Facebook. Would love this book. I've read it, and the author did such a wonderful job writing about such a sad subject. I wish I had such a way with words.
Jill L
chipdip2010(at)hotmail(dot)com
Raven Waldenpond says
Sounds like a book I would enjoy
Anita Yancey says
I am an email subscriber!
ayancey(at)dishmail(dot)net
Raven Waldenpond says
Sounds like a book I would enjoy
Anita Yancey says
I am an email subscriber!
ayancey(at)dishmail(dot)net
Merrie L. says
I follow the Review Broads
Merrie L. says
I'm subscribe via email.
Merrie L. says
I follow Bro'B's new blog – I Pity the Blog!
Lockwoodmerrie@yahoo.com
Merrie L. says
I follow the Review Broads
Merrie L. says
I'm subscribe via email.
Merrie L. says
I follow Bro'B's new blog – I Pity the Blog!
Lockwoodmerrie@yahoo.com
tawnda says
google follower
tawnda says
google follower
Anonymous says
follower on twitter
Anonymous says
follower on twitter
Anita Yancey says
I am a follower!
ayancey(at)dishmail(dot)net
Anita Yancey says
I am a follower!
ayancey(at)dishmail(dot)net
jodi233 says
i am a follower too
jodi233@comcast.net
Shelly says
subscriber
michelejdaley at gmail dot com
Shelly says
follower
michelejdaley at gmail dot com
Shelly says
follow I Pity the Blog
michelejdaley at gmail dot com
Shelly says
twitter follower @phxbne
michelejdaley at gmail dot com
jodi233 says
i am a follower too
jodi233@comcast.net
Shelly says
subscriber
michelejdaley at gmail dot com
Shelly says
follower
michelejdaley at gmail dot com
Shelly says
follow I Pity the Blog
michelejdaley at gmail dot com
Shelly says
twitter follower @phxbne
michelejdaley at gmail dot com
Cheryl B says
facebook fan of the review broads:
Cheryl Newman Bradley (cln1812)
cln1812(at)gmail(dot)com
Cheryl B says
blogged about it here:
http://proudboobymama.blogspot.com/2010/02/feb-15-giveaways.html
cln1812(at)gmail(dot)com
Cheryl B says
follow the review broads on google friend connect:
Cheryl Bradley
cln1812(at)gmail(dot)com
Cheryl B says
email subscriber to the review broads:
cln1812(at)gmail(dot)com
Cheryl B says
shared on facebook:
Cheryl Newman Bradley (cln1812)
cln1812(at)gmail(dot)com
FB link:
http://www.facebook.com/cln1812?v=app_2309869772#!/cln1812?v=feed&story_fbid=310856036458&ref=share
Cheryl B says
follow i pity the blog on GFC:
cln1812(at)gmail(dot)com
Cheryl Bradley
Cheryl B says
follow z on twitter @cln1812
cln1812(at)gmail(dot)com
Cheryl B says
2/15 tweet:
http://twitter.com/cln1812/status/9170553567
cln1812(at)gmail(dot)com
Cheryl B says
facebook fan of the review broads:
Cheryl Newman Bradley (cln1812)
cln1812(at)gmail(dot)com
Cheryl B says
blogged about it here:
http://proudboobymama.blogspot.com/2010/02/feb-15-giveaways.html
cln1812(at)gmail(dot)com
Cheryl B says
follow the review broads on google friend connect:
Cheryl Bradley
cln1812(at)gmail(dot)com
Cheryl B says
email subscriber to the review broads:
cln1812(at)gmail(dot)com
Cheryl B says
shared on facebook:
Cheryl Newman Bradley (cln1812)
cln1812(at)gmail(dot)com
FB link:
http://www.facebook.com/cln1812?v=app_2309869772#!/cln1812?v=feed&story_fbid=310856036458&ref=share
Cheryl B says
follow i pity the blog on GFC:
cln1812(at)gmail(dot)com
Cheryl Bradley
Cheryl B says
follow z on twitter @cln1812
cln1812(at)gmail(dot)com
Cheryl B says
2/15 tweet:
http://twitter.com/cln1812/status/9170553567
cln1812(at)gmail(dot)com
Mary says
I'm an email subscriber 🙂
mamie316(at)sbcglobal(dot)net
Mary says
I'm a Facebook fan.
mamie316(at)sbcglobal(dot)net
Mary says
I'm an email subscriber 🙂
mamie316(at)sbcglobal(dot)net
Mary says
I'm a Facebook fan.
mamie316(at)sbcglobal(dot)net
CindyWindy2003 says
Follow the Review Broads, carawling(at)hotmail(dot)com
CindyWindy2003 says
Subscribe to this blog via email, carawling(at)hotmail(dot)com
CindyWindy2003 says
Follow Bro'B's new blog – I Pity the Blog, carawling(at)hotmail(dot)com
CindyWindy2003 says
Follow Broad “Z” on twitter. @carafferty, carawling(at)hotmail(dot)com
CindyWindy2003 says
Badge on blog, http://cindywindylovesblogsnfrogs.blogspot.com/ carawling(at)hotmail(dot)com
CindyWindy2003 says
tweet http://twitter.com/carafferty/status/9248770736
crawling(at)hotmail(dot)com
CindyWindy2003 says
Follow the Review Broads, carawling(at)hotmail(dot)com
CindyWindy2003 says
Subscribe to this blog via email, carawling(at)hotmail(dot)com
CindyWindy2003 says
Follow Bro'B's new blog – I Pity the Blog, carawling(at)hotmail(dot)com
CindyWindy2003 says
Follow Broad “Z” on twitter. @carafferty, carawling(at)hotmail(dot)com
CindyWindy2003 says
Badge on blog, http://cindywindylovesblogsnfrogs.blogspot.com/ carawling(at)hotmail(dot)com
CindyWindy2003 says
tweet http://twitter.com/carafferty/status/9248770736
crawling(at)hotmail(dot)com
Mary says
I'm an email subscriber.
mamie316(at)sbcglobal(dot)net
Mary says
I follow on Google Friend.
mamie316(at)sbcglobal(dot)net
Mary says
I'm a Facebook fan.
mamie316(at)sbcglobal(dot)net
Mary says
I'm an email subscriber.
mamie316(at)sbcglobal(dot)net
Mary says
I follow on Google Friend.
mamie316(at)sbcglobal(dot)net
Mary says
I'm a Facebook fan.
mamie316(at)sbcglobal(dot)net
Cheryl B says
2/17 tweet:
http://twitter.com/cln1812/status/9265774164
cln1812(at)gmail(dot)com
Cheryl B says
2/17 tweet:
http://twitter.com/cln1812/status/9265774164
cln1812(at)gmail(dot)com
Terra H. says
email subscriber
partymix25(at)hotmail(dot)com
Terra H. says
I follow your blog.
partymix25(at)hotmail(dot)com
jodi233 says
following i pity the blog
jodi233@comcast.net
Terra H. says
email subscriber
partymix25(at)hotmail(dot)com
Terra H. says
I follow your blog.
partymix25(at)hotmail(dot)com
jodi233 says
following i pity the blog
jodi233@comcast.net
Cheryl B says
2/18 tweet:
http://twitter.com/cln1812/status/9314709030
cln1812(at)gmail(dot)com
Cheryl B says
2/18 tweet:
http://twitter.com/cln1812/status/9314709030
cln1812(at)gmail(dot)com
Benita says
Email subscriber.
bgcchs(at)yahoo(dot)com
Benita says
Follower of I Pity the Blog.
bgcchs(at)yahoo(dot)com
Benita says
Email subscriber.
bgcchs(at)yahoo(dot)com
Benita says
Follower of I Pity the Blog.
bgcchs(at)yahoo(dot)com
Kelly says
Follow Broad Z on twitter.
http://twitter.com/sarafan2
Kelly says
Follow Broad Z on twitter.
http://twitter.com/sarafan2
alovelydissenter says
Tweet: http://twitter.com/lovelydissenter/status/9479623772
iluvvanillacoke6(at)yahoo(dot)com
alovelydissenter says
Tweet: http://twitter.com/lovelydissenter/status/9479623772
iluvvanillacoke6(at)yahoo(dot)com
Julie says
follow RB
aunteegem@yahoo.com
Julie says
email subscsriber
aunteegem@yahoo.com
Julie says
FB fan-
aunteegem@yahoo.com
Julie says
follow RB
aunteegem@yahoo.com
Julie says
email subscsriber
aunteegem@yahoo.com
Julie says
FB fan-
aunteegem@yahoo.com
Cheryl B says
2/22 tweet:
http://twitter.com/cln1812/status/9510903977
cln1812(at)gmail(dot)com
Cheryl B says
2/22 tweet:
http://twitter.com/cln1812/status/9510903977
cln1812(at)gmail(dot)com
Cheryl B says
2/24 tweet:
http://twitter.com/cln1812/status/9601941971
cln1812(at)gmail(dot)com
Cheryl B says
2/24 tweet:
http://twitter.com/cln1812/status/9601941971
cln1812(at)gmail(dot)com
Nancye says
Facebook Fan
nancyecdavis AT bellsouth DOT net
Nancye says
Follower
nancyecdavis AT bellsouth DOT net
Nancye says
E-mail subbscriber
nancyecdavis AT bellsouth DOT net
Nancye says
I follow Bro 'B “I Pity the Blog”
nancyecdavis AT bellsouth DOT net
Nancye says
I follow Broad Z on Twitter
nancyecdavis AT bellsouth DOT net
Nancye says
Tweet! Tweet!
http://twitter.com/NancyeDavis/status/9605065194
nancyecdavis AT bellsouth DOT net
Nancye says
Facebook Fan
nancyecdavis AT bellsouth DOT net
Nancye says
Follower
nancyecdavis AT bellsouth DOT net
Nancye says
E-mail subbscriber
nancyecdavis AT bellsouth DOT net
Nancye says
I follow Bro 'B “I Pity the Blog”
nancyecdavis AT bellsouth DOT net
Nancye says
I follow Broad Z on Twitter
nancyecdavis AT bellsouth DOT net
Nancye says
Tweet! Tweet!
http://twitter.com/NancyeDavis/status/9605065194
nancyecdavis AT bellsouth DOT net
Nancy S. says
I follow your blog with google friend.
ncschools at yahoo dot com
Nancy S. says
I subscribe to your feed.
Nancy S. says
I follow Bro B's blog.
Nancy S. says
I follow Broad Z on twitter – ncschools.
Nancy S. says
I tweeted.
http://twitter.com/ncschools/status/9609454266
Swtlilchick says
Fan of The Broads on Facebook (Charlene Kuser)
CharlieGurl57@aol.com
Swtlilchick says
Following the Review Broads (Charlene)
CharlieGurl57@aol.com
Swtlilchick says
Subscriber to The Review Broads
CharlieGurl57@aol.com
Swtlilchick says
Tweeted:Swtlilchick
http://twitter.com/Swtlilchick/status/9611539218
CharlieGurl57@aol.com
Swtlilchick says
Following I Pity the Blog (Charlene)
CharlieGurl57@aol.com
Nancy S. says
I follow your blog with google friend.
ncschools at yahoo dot com
Nancy S. says
I subscribe to your feed.
Nancy S. says
I follow Bro B's blog.
Nancy S. says
I follow Broad Z on twitter – ncschools.
Nancy S. says
I tweeted.
http://twitter.com/ncschools/status/9609454266
Swtlilchick says
Followiing Broad “Z” on twitter (@Swtlilchick)
CharlieGurl57@aol.com
lilyk says
I subscribed to your blog.
lilyk@mail2world.com
lilyk says
I became your Facebook fan.
lilyk@mail2world.com
Swtlilchick says
Fan of The Broads on Facebook (Charlene Kuser)
CharlieGurl57@aol.com
Swtlilchick says
Following the Review Broads (Charlene)
CharlieGurl57@aol.com
Swtlilchick says
Subscriber to The Review Broads
CharlieGurl57@aol.com
Swtlilchick says
Tweeted:Swtlilchick
http://twitter.com/Swtlilchick/status/9611539218
CharlieGurl57@aol.com
Swtlilchick says
Following I Pity the Blog (Charlene)
CharlieGurl57@aol.com
Swtlilchick says
Followiing Broad “Z” on twitter (@Swtlilchick)
CharlieGurl57@aol.com
lilyk says
I subscribed to your blog.
lilyk@mail2world.com
lilyk says
I became your Facebook fan.
lilyk@mail2world.com